04/18/2017

Declining Living Standards? New Research Finds 164% Increase In Consumption For Low-Income Americans From 1960-2015

Mark J. Perry, American Enterprise Institute

Greg Mankiw recently pointed to an NBER research paper “Fifty Years of Growth in American Consumption, Income, and Wages,” by Bruce Sacerdote, with some really interesting results and findings that run counter to the media narrative of a stagnating/disappearing/struggling middle class in America. Some key excerpts appear below (emphasis mine):

The paper’s abstract:

Despite the large increase in U.S. income inequality, consumption for families at the 25th and 50th percentiles of income has grown steadily over the time period 1960-2015. The number of cars per household with below median income has doubled since 1980 and the number of bedrooms per household has grown 10% despite decreases in household size. The finding of zero growth in American real wages since the 1970s is driven in part by the choice of the CPI-U as the price deflator; small biases in any price deflator compound over long periods of time. Using a different deflator such as the Personal Consumption Expenditures index (PCE) yields modest growth in real wages and in median household incomes throughout the time period. Accounting for the Hamilton (1998) and Costa (2001) estimates of CPI bias yields estimated wage growth of 1% per year during 1975-2015. Meaningful growth in consumption for below median income families has occurred even in a prolonged period of increasing income inequality, increasing consumption inequality and a decreasing share of national income accruing to labor.

From the introduction:

Nearly every week Americans are greeted with headlines such as “Millennials Earn Less Than Their Parents,” “America’s Productivity Climbs But Wages Stagnate,” and “For Most Workers, Real Wages Have Barely Budged For Decades.” The finding of almost no real wage growth since 1975 comes from taking the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Average Hourly Earnings of Production and Non-Supervisory Workers and using the CPI-Urban to inflate wages to 2015 dollars. Focusing only on these particular price and wage series gives policy makers, citizens and workers an incomplete picture because the choice of price deflator makes a big difference. Most economists believe that the CPI includes upward biases which compound significantly over time. Overstating price growth mechanically implies understating real wage growth.

In the first part of this descriptive paper I consider growth in household consumption for households with below median income. The pessimistic narrative on real wages is somewhat at odds with casual empiricism about material goods consumption. If you spend time working with high school students, you notice that even in low income areas, many of the students have cell phones and have access to cable TV and internet service at home. Access to these powerful and modern tools suggests that low income families have seen important gains in at least some areas of consumption. The quality and variety of home appliances and electronics (TVs) in the average home is surely vastly superior to what people owned in the 1970s. American homes have become more spacious and cars are both higher quality and there are more cars per family.

Read full article



You May Also Like:

Democrats Had No Business Winning In Alabama John Podhoretz, New York Post

Republicans Have A Final Deal On Their Tax Bill — Here's What's In It Bob Bryan, Business Insider

Steve Bannon's Big Loss In Alabama Roger L. Simon, PJ Media

‘We Can’t Take That Risk’ — FBI Officials Discussed ‘Insurance Policy’ Against Trump Presidency Chuck Ross, Daily Caller

Report: Wait Times For Canada Gov. Health Care 128% Higher Than In ‘93 Bacchus Barua, Fraser Institute

The Left's 'Reverse Robin Hood' Tax Reform Narrative Is Bunk Bernie Marcus, The Hill

Illinois Drives People Away The Wall Street Journal

Double Standards And Distortions Heather Mac Donald, City Journal

Pete King Blasts ‘Disheveled Drunk’ Steve Bannon Bob Fredericks, New York Post

Report: Lawyer Caught Offering Woman $200,000 To Accuse Trump Of Sex Assault V. Saxena, Conservative Tribune

Government Should Leave Bakers Alone Ron Paul, Ron Paul Institute for Peace and Prosperity

100 Years. 100 Million Lives. Think Twice. Laura M. Nicolae, Harvard Crimson

Liberate Food Trucks [Watch] John Stossel, Townhall

While Everyone Was Distracted By Alabama Election, Senate Passed Tight Vote To Give Trump A Huge Victory Warner Todd Huston, American News Hub

Skyrocketing University President Salaries Paid For By Student Debt Brendan Pringle, Washington Examiner

As Robot Sales Increase, So Will Jobs For Humans Allan Golombek, RealClearMarkets

A New Stealth Attack In EU’s “War On Cash” Don Quijones, Wolf Street

For More go to the Home Page >>>

Join Our Email List



Bookshelf

FreeMarket Central

Some titles recent, all recommended -

Special Video Feature

FreeMarket Central

Voices From The 2017 International Students For Liberty Conference

In Search Of History

The Reagan Tax Cuts Worked

Thanks to "bracket creep," the inflation of the 1970s pushed millions of taxpayers into higher tax brackets even though their inflation-adjusted incomes were not rising. To help offset this tax increase and also to improve incentives to work, save, and invest, President Reagan proposed sweeping tax rate reductions during the 1980s. What happened? Total tax revenues climbed by 99.4 percent during the 1980s, and the results are even more impressive when looking at what happened to personal income tax revenues. Once the economy received an unambiguous tax cut in January 1983, income tax revenues climbed dramatically, increasing by more than 54 percent by 1989 (28 percent after adjusting for inflation).

 

-- Daniel J. Mitchell,

Shadow Stats Snapshot


FreeMarket Central

ShadowStats alternate economic indicators are based on the methodology of noted economist John Williams, specialist in government economic reporting.

  • Unemployment:
    FreeMarket Central BLS: 4.12%
    FreeMarket Central Shadow Stats: 21.7%
  • Inflation:
    FreeMarket Central November Year-to-Year: 2.04% (CPI-U*)
    FreeMarket Central Shadow Stats: 9.8%

*[cpi-u is the Bureau of Labor Statistics inflation rate for all urban consumers]