04/18/2017

A Twisted Tale Of Rent Control In The Maximum City

Alex Tabarrok, Marginal Revolution

Walking around Mumbai it’s common to see some lovely, older buildings (circa 1920s perhaps) that are in a great state of disrepair. A well maintained building can last for hundreds of years so why are these buildings falling apart? The answer is rent control. Bombay passed a rent control act in 1947 that froze rents at 1940 levels.

rentcontrol1

 

More than fifty years later, rents remained frozen at 1940 levels. It wasn’t until 1999 that the Act was modified slightly to lift controls on some new construction and to allow rent increases of 4% per year. After a fifty two year freeze, however, a 4% increase was a pittance. Thus, even today there are thousands of flats where tenants are paying rents of 400-500 rupees a month (that’s $6 to $8 a month!)–far, far below market rates.

The rent control law meant that there was virtually no construction of rental housing (WP) for decades and a slowly dilapidating housing stock. (Ironically, the only free market in rental housing is in the slums.)

The nominal landlords have neither the incentive nor the funds to maintain the buildings so every year during monsoon season some of the buildings collapse and people die. As the World Bank put it, the monsoons are Natural Hazards but the collapses are Unnatural Disasters:

Rent controls in Mumbai may have initially benefited tenants at the expense of landlords, but over time everyone suffers. Rent controls cause landlords to forgo maintenance and neglect their properties, and tenants not only live in dilapidated buildings but die when they collapse in heavy rains. Even if tenants are willing to either pay higher rents or to maintain the building, each tries to not pay his share of the expense (free riding), especially if appropriate retrofitting involves structural changes to the entire residential structure and not to individual apartments. Tenants also may lack the legal authority to make changes to their building’s structure.

Consider the photo at top, it’s an elegant building on a nice plot in a highly desirable part of town but take a closer look and you can see that it is falling apart (second photo). Several businesses and flats operate in the building. Now read the sign on the wall.

rentcontrol3I don’t doubt that the sign is largely accurate but it also illustrates another aspect of rent control. Rent control transforms a mutually profitable exchange into a zero-sum war of misery. As I discovered in my investigations, a remarkable and sometimes hilarious example is illustrated by this very building.

Read full article



You May Also Like:

Black Police Officer On NFL Protest: "Now I Have Had Enough" [Watch] Brandon Tatum, YouTube

Ted Cruz Just Stuck A Fork In The Graham-Cassidy ObamaCare Repeal/Replace Bill streiff, RedState

ObamaCare’s Tax On The Poor The Wall Street Journal

How Obama Is Funding The Anti-Trump Resistance Paul Sperry, New York Post

John McCain: Obamacare Savior Guy Benson, Townhall

NFL Picked Sides In The Culture War, Now It Has To Live With The Consequences William A. Jacobson, Legal Insurrection

Trump Tells NFL Fans To Stop Going To Games 'Until Players Stop Disrespecting Our Flag & Country’ [Watch] Joseph Weber, Fox News

NFL Team Owner Shahid Khan Joins NFL's National Anthem Protests USA Today

It Was The Deep State That Colluded With The Russians, Not Trump Clarice Feldman, American Thinker

Theresa May Prepares To Leave The EU John O’Sullivan, National Review

Showdown Looms: FBI Misses Third Deadline To Turn Over Subpoenaed Trump Dossier Docs Byron York, Washington Examiner

Global Warming: Who Are The Deniers Now? Investor’s Business Daily

If Trade 'Deficits' Are Bad, Why Do Rich Countries Have Them? Allan Golombek, RealClearMarkets

Reminder: Obama Paid The NFL Millions To Be Patriotic Timothy Meads, Townhall

Can The Sugary Beverage Tax! John O. McGinnis, Library of Law and Liberty

California Legislature Demands Apology From Trump Casey Ryan, Daily Signal

NFL Issues Official Statement On Donald Trump Brian Thomas, Federalist Papers Project

Solar Panels Perfect Case Of Protectionism Costing More Jobs Than It Saves Jeffrey Dorfman, Forbes.com

What Did The Founders Think About Freedom Of Speech? Mike Sabo, American Greatness

For More go to the Home Page >>>

Search

SIGN OUR PETITION

FreeMarket Central

TELL CONGRESS: STOP THE POLITICS.

PASS A HEALTH CARE BILL THAT PUTS PATIENTS FIRST



Americans need a health care bill that serves needs of individuals—not those of Washington and big corporations.

 

Read more

Bookshelf

FreeMarket Central

Some titles recent, all recommended -

Special Video Feature

FreeMarket Central

Voices From The 2017 International Students For Liberty Conference

In Search Of History

When America Was Truly The Land Of Opportunity

For [early immigrants] America was truly the land of opportunity. For the first time in their lives, many were truly free to pursue their own objectives. That freedom released the human energies which created the United States. There were few government programs to turn to and nobody expected them. But also there were few rules and regulations. There were no licenses, no permits, no red tape to restrict them. They found, in fact, a free market, and most of them thrived on it. 

-- Milton Friedman,

Shadow Stats Snapshot


FreeMarket Central

ShadowStats alternate economic indicators are based on the methodology of noted economist John Williams, specialist in government economic reporting.

  • Unemployment:
    FreeMarket Central BLS: 4.44%
    FreeMarket Central Shadow Stats: 22.2%
  • Inflation:
    FreeMarket Central August Year-to-Year: 1.73% (CPI-U*)
    FreeMarket Central Shadow Stats: 9.4%

*[cpi-u is the Bureau of Labor Statistics inflation rate for all urban consumers]