01/12/2017

Hey Hollywood, Smugness Isn't A Political Strategy

Megan McArdle, Bloomberg

Ah, Hollywood awards season. It must be time for celebrities to don gorgeous clothes, have each individual hair arranged by some stylist who charges by the femtosecond, and get up on stage to advocate for some political cause — and for the rest of us to spend days arguing about what they said.

This election cycle has been unusually vicious and angry, and therefore, of course, the controversy is as well. Meryl Streep has delivered a rebuke to Donald Trump, and now social media is convulsed by debate over a blandly unobjectionable point: Trump was wrong to make fun of a disabled reporter’s handicap.

Out of self-protection, some commentators retreat to the meta-debate: Should entertainers even make political statements? Actors are chosen for pulchritude and emotional plasticity, not for their ability to grasp fine policy distinctions or complex moral reasoning, so why on earth do they presume to lecture the rest of us? And isn’t it bad for business?

Well, yes, celebrities are stupid about policy, often breathtakingly so. On the other hand, so is everyone else. You want to hear some really stupid ideas about policy? Grab a group of whip-smart financial wizards, or neurosurgeons, or nuclear physicists, and sit them down for a nice dinner to debate some policy outside their profession. You will find that they are pretty much just as stupid as anyone else, because policy is not about smart. I mean, smart helps. But policy is fundamentally about domain knowledge, and that knowledge is acquired only by spending a great deal of time thinking about a pretty small set of problems. Funnily enough, this is also how one gets good at finance, or neurosurgery, or nuclear physics.

Read full article



You May Also Like:

Revenge Of The Deep State Andrew Napolitano, Reason

At CPAC, Walker Urges Republican Leaders To 'Go Big, Go Bold’ [Watch] Fox News

Consumers Will Take The Biggest Hit From Trump Border Adjustment Tax Paula Rosenblum, Forbes.com

How Did America Get Stuck With A Regulatory State? Scott Rasmussen, RealClearPolitics

James O’Keefe Offers $10,000 Awards For Evidence Of ‘Media Malfeasance’ [Watch] Bradford Richardson, Washington Times

Trump, Milo, And The War On Cops Heather Mac Donald, City Journal

FREE Stuff Vs. FREE-dom: CPAC Panel Deconstructs Millennials’ Love Affair With Bernie [Watch] American Conservative Union

Everyone Is Wrong About Milo And CPAC Ben Domenech, The Federalist

Kushner, Ivanka Trump Got Words Against Climate Deal Nixed From Coming Executive Order Amy Harder and Peter Nicholas, Wall Street Journal

In Show Of Unity, Bannon, Priebus Address CPAC And The ‘Opposition’ [Watch] Joel B. Pollak, Breitbart News

Seriously, Don't Watch The Oscars Jonathan V. Last, Weekly Standard

Remembering Alan Colmes, A Liberal Who Could Laugh [Watch] Howard Kurtz, Fox News

European Welfare Benefits Help Fund ISIS Fighters Kim Hjelmgaard, USA Today

US Debt Falls By $12 Billion In Trump’s First Month Jim Hoft, Gateway Pundit

The 10 Worst Colleges For Free Speech: 2017 Greg Lukianoff, Huffington Post

Pelosi Breakdown? Repeats Words, Tells Audience To Clap, Kasich ‘Gov Of Illinois’ [Watch] Kyle Olson, American Mirror

The Tyranny Of A Cashless Society Coming? Capt. William E. Simpson, Western Journalism

California: The Physical Collapse Of A Social State Thomas Del Beccaro, Forbes.com

For More go to the Home Page >>>

Search



Bookshelf



Some titles recent, all recommended -

Special Video Feature



Voices From The 2017 International Students For Liberty Conference

In Search Of History

Hillsdale College History Prof. Burton Folsom: What The Invention of the Airplane Teaches About Free Markets

The behind-the-scenes story of the airplane demonstrates how private enterprise is needed for innovation and economic growth— and that government subsidies usually fail.

Shadow Stats Snapshot


ShadowStats alternate economic indicators are based on the methodology of noted economist John Williams, specialist in government economic reporting.

  • Unemployment:
    BLS: 4.7%
    Shadow Stats: 22.7%
  • Inflation:
    January Year-to-Year: 2.50% (CPI-U*)
    Shadow Stats: 10.3%

*[cpi-u is the Bureau of Labor Statistics inflation rate for all urban consumers]