01/12/2017

Why Republicans Should Let ObamaCare Self Destruct

Jane M. Orient, M.D., Heartland Institute

The Trump Administration and the Republican Congress is faced with a crisis in the Affordable Care Act.

Suppose you are a surgeon who is called to see a patient who is bleeding from something in his abdomen. You are to consider an exploratory operation to try to find the bleeding point and stop the hemorrhage.

The problem is that the patient has widely metastatic cancer. He has already mostly depleted the blood bank’s supply of his blood type. His clotting factors have gotten so diluted that it will be hard to control bleeding from surgery. He is already on the brink of multi-organ failure. His cancer is untreatable.

Should you tell the operating room to get ready? You might have a successful operation and keep the patient going a few months longer. Maybe the Obama Cancer Moonshot will have discovered a cure by then.

But almost certainly the patient will either die on the operating table, or a few days or weeks later, during which time some alleged error or complication will have occurred. And the surgeon, without doubt, will be blamed.

The surgeon will most likely decide that the patient is not an operative candidate. If unwilling to say so, he might just send the patient for more tests until the inevitable makes the question of surgery moot.

Now the Trump Administration and the Republican Congress is faced with a crisis in the Affordable Care Act. Most of the co-ops are gone. A large portion of the exchanges have only one plan to “choose” from. The money appropriated for shoring up insurance companies that experience losses is used up, and the Administration’s illegal attempt to take money from other sources such as the Judgment Fund has run into a court challenge.

The patient named ACA has been in trouble since the beginning, but Dr. Obama has intervened unilaterally to save it with exemptions for powerful players (such as some big companies and a “small business” comprised of congressional staffers) and other types of executive finesse.

But now the Republicans are about to take charge. They have been promising, and dithering, and delaying, and gesticulating about using the power of the purse to stop this Democrat-created disaster since 2010. But now the whole health system is in trouble as ACA tentacles are deeply entwined in it, and millions of patients are counting on ACA health plans. Whatever Congress does will have complications, and if the bipartisan fix or replacement has Republican fingerprints, the Republicans will be blamed.

A number of Republican ideas have been floated, and the differences between them are not trivial. Repeal the new taxes, or keep them but redistribute the takings in a different way? Restore hundreds of billions in Medicare cuts, or keep them in order to stay “revenue neutral”? Get rid of the individual mandate, or admit that without increasingly heavy coercion, young and healthy people will not pay the enormous premiums needed to subsidize the chronically ill? The very popular protection for people with pre-existing conditions will inevitably destroy insurance.

At this point, the Republican Congress might be best advised to continue doing what it does best: keep talking. Send the patient for more tests.

But the nation’s economy, the medical system, and our patients must be freed from the grip of the [Un]affordable Care Act. That monster must die—of its inherent disease, which was created solely by Democrats. Congress, if it can’t do something right, needs to do nothing.

It’s up to the executive branch to embrace its constitutional duty:

  • Stop illegal actions that have been resuscitating ACA and permitting its cancer to spread;
  • Stop enforcing unconstitutional law; and
  • Reverse the regulations that are blocking the development of better alternatives.

Trump could take these actions immediately:

  • Withdraw the Administration’s appeal of the lawsuit that prevents funding insurers without congressional appropriations (U.S. House of Representatives v. Burwell);
  • Order the IRS not to enforce the individual mandate;
  • Repeal regulations that require a comprehensive benefits package, and allow insurers to offer low-cost plans;
  • Greatly liberalize requirements for Health Savings Accounts.

Those who like their ObamaCare plan could keep it—they just couldn’t force younger, healthier subscribers, or current and yet-unborn taxpayers to pay for it. But once allowed to escape from bureaucratic restraints, most Americans will choose something better.

Read full article



You May Also Like:

The French Election: We May Have Avoided A Political And Economic Cataclysm Steve Forbes, Forbes.com

Fox News To Become More Like Despised Competitor [Watch] Art Moore, WND

GOP Border Tax Will Build A Wall Around Consumers Matthew Kandrach, RealClearPolitics

Thanks To Democrats, Pre-Existing Conditions Outweigh The Uninsured In The GOP Obamacare Deal [Watch] Avik Roy, Forbes.com

Judge Jeanine: 'Time To Fight Back' Against ‘Snowflakes’ Trampling On Free Speech [Watch] Fox News

France Will Now Choose Between Two Outsiders, Macron And Le Pen John Fund, National Review

No 2018 Landslide? Trump And GOP See Polls Improve, While Dems Sink Ryan Girdusky, Red Alert Politics

Ann Coulter’s Important Lesson: Appeasement Always Fails Derek Hunter, Townhall

Berkeley Antifa Activist Who Beat Trump Supporter With Bike Lock Identified As ‘Ethics’ Professor [Watch] Jim Hoft, Gateway Pundit

This May Be Venezuela’s Tiananmen Square Moment [Watch] Ana Quintana, Daily Signal

ABC/Wapo Poll: 98 Percent Of Trump Voters Happy With Their Choice Cathy Burke, Newsmax

President Trump Marks First Visit To Walter Reed By Hand-Delivering Purple Heart To Wounded Vet [Watch] Virginia Kruta, Independent Journal Review

No, Gov. Dean, There Is No ‘Hate Speech’ Exception To The First Amendment Eugene Volokh, Washington Post

Bill Nye Blows Gasket When A Real Scientist Schools Him On Facts About ‘Climate Change’ [Watch] Chris Enloe, The Blaze

How Africa Got Left Behind Marian L. Tupy, Foundation for Economic Education

Socialist Death Squads Rule Venezuela John Hinderaker, Powerline Blog

13 Most Ridiculous Predictions Made On Earth Day, 1970 Jon Gabriel, Ricochet

Democrats File Federal Lawsuit To Try To Steal The Georgia Special Election Erick Erickson, The Resurgent

Visualizing The Collapse Of The Middle Class In 20 Major U.S. Cities Tyler Durden, Zero Hedge

Chelsea Clinton: Little Creep Kevin D. Williamson, National Review

Bottling Up Free Trade: Challenging MN’s Bad Wine Laws [Watch] Institute for Justice

For More go to the Home Page >>>

Search

Bookshelf

SHARE

Some titles recent, all recommended -

Special Video Feature



Voices From The 2017 International Students For Liberty Conference

In Search Of History

SHARE

Keynesian Economics and the Great Depression

Hillsdale College economics professor Gary Wolfram discusses Keynesian economics and the factors that pulled the national economy out of the Great Depression. The story of World War II shows that government spending may produce activity, but not the prosperity of a truly healthy economy.

 

-- Gary Wolfram, Hillsdale College,

Shadow Stats Snapshot


ShadowStats alternate economic indicators are based on the methodology of noted economist John Williams, specialist in government economic reporting.

  • Unemployment:
    BLS: 4.5%
    Shadow Stats: 22.5%
  • Inflation:
    March Year-to-Year: 2.74% (CPI-U*)
    Shadow Stats: 10.5%

*[cpi-u is the Bureau of Labor Statistics inflation rate for all urban consumers]