01/02/2017

The PC Police Crack Down On . . . Kids Books

Megan Cox Gurdon, Wall Street Journal

Ranking high among the surrealities of 2016 was the meltdown at a literary festival in Australia when the American-born novelist Lionel Shriver defended the freedom of fiction writers to conjure characters unlike themselves.

“Taken to their logical conclusion,” Ms. Shriver warned, “ideologies recently come into vogue challenge our right to write fiction at all.” Among the concepts she skewered was “cultural appropriation,” the notion that members of one ethnic group mustn’t use (or eat or wear or write about) things emanating from other ethnic groups. The illogical impracticality of the idea, especially with fiction, hasn’t impeded its spread, and the resulting umbrage was a wonder to behold: An Australian writer of Egyptian and Sudanese origin stormed out of the speech, later blaming Ms. Shriver for celebrating “the unfettered exploitation of the experiences of others, under the guise of fiction.” The officials in charge of the event disavowed their keynote speaker’s remarks.

Such exquisite sensitivities put a lot of well-meaning people into terrible predicaments in 2016. In the children’s literary realm, where “diversity” has become the lodestar, the year began and ended with choler, indignation and the repudiation of books.

In January, after a two-week social-media drumming, Scholastic pulled from distribution “A Birthday Cake for George Washington, ” which was criticized for an excessively jolly portrayal of enslaved people in the first president’s household. The picture book valorized Hercules, Washington’s chef, who is regarded as America’s first celebrity cook and who, in the story, dazzles his daughter by confecting a cake without sugar. That the book was written by Ramin Ganeshram, a woman of Iranian-Trinidadian descent, and was illustrated and edited by two African-American women, Vanessa Brantley-Newton and Andrea Davis Pinkney respectively, did not soften the opprobrium.

That controversy was reminiscent of an earlier one, when ignominy befell author Emily Jenkins and illustrator Sophie Blackall, who are white, for their 2015 picture book “A Fine Dessert,” published by Schwartz + Wade. The story traces four centuries of social and domestic change by showing the evolving ways in which families have prepared a sweet dish called blackberry fool. The book’s crime, to its detractors, was what one called the story’s “degrading” depiction of an enslaved mother and daughter in 1810 enjoying themselves as they make and taste the dessert.

That controversy was reminiscent of an earlier one, when ignominy befell author Emily Jenkins and illustrator Sophie Blackall, who are white, for their 2015 picture book “A Fine Dessert,” published by Schwartz + Wade. The story traces four centuries of social and domestic change by showing the evolving ways in which families have prepared a sweet dish called blackberry fool. The book’s crime, to its detractors, was what one called the story’s “degrading” depiction of an enslaved mother and daughter in 1810 enjoying themselves as they make and taste the dessert.

In July, controversy swirled around Lane Smith ’s picture book “There Is a Tribe of Kids” (which publisher Roaring Brook did not recall) for representing children in a natural setting with feathers in their hair (see below)—as if, critics said, they were “playing Indian.” In August, Candlewick recalled copies of E.E. Charlton-Trujillo’s young-adult novel “When We Was Fierce.” Early critical praise had morphed into social-media wrath over the author’s use of an invented urban dialect that was, in the words of one prominent fault-finder, “deeply insensitive.”

[Subscription required.]

Read full article



You May Also Like:

President Trump: Replace The Dollar With Gold As The Global Currency To Make America Great Again Ralph Benko, Forbes.com

‘Big Government’ Is Ever Growing, On The Sly George Will, National Review

Meet The Terrorist Behind The Next Women’s March [Watch] Kyle Smith, New York Post

Trump: Grating Style, Significant Substance Michael Barone, Washington Examiner

Republican Obamacare Repeal Plan LEAKS: 6 Good Ideas, 4 Bad Ones Ben Shapiro, The Daily Wire

Straightforward From Here To The Left’s Fascist, Maybe Violent, Endgame [Watch] Kurt Schlicter, Townhall

Trump's Right, The Debt Has Fallen $12 Billion - It's Nothing To Do With Trump Though Tim Worstall, Forbes.com

British Commentator: The Left “Is Staring At Its Own Electoral Demise" Mark Tapson, Truth Revolt

Thomas Perez Dropped Voter Intimidation Charges Against Black Panthers Who Brought Weapon To Polling Place [Watch] Jim Hoft, The Gateway Pundit

New EPA Administrator: Executive Agencies “Can’t Make It Up As They Go" [Watch] Rachel del Guidice, Daily Signal

Transgender Wrestler Wins Girls State Title As Texas Rule Draws Criticism Dan Frosch and Tawnell D. Hobbs, The Wall Street Journal

God Help Us If Chelsea Clinton Runs For Office [Watch] Maureen Callahan, New York Post

Reimporting Drugs Will Not Bring Down Prices Matthew Glans, The Heartland Institute

Oscars Poll: 66 Percent Of Trump Voters Turn Off Awards Shows When Speeches Get Political [Watch] The Hollywood Reporter

How Americans Can Live, And Thrive, With Intense Political Disagreement William McKenzie, Dallas News

The Totally Bizarre, Incredible, Loony Tunes Story Of The Death Of Kim Jong Un's Half Brother [Watch] Rick Moran, PJ Media

Betsy DeVos At CPAC Calls Out Leftist Educators For Brainwashing Students [Watch] Louder With Crowder

For More go to the Home Page >>>

Search



Bookshelf



Some titles recent, all recommended -

Special Video Feature



Voices From The 2017 International Students For Liberty Conference

In Search Of History

Hillsdale College History Prof. Burton Folsom: What The Invention of the Airplane Teaches About Free Markets

The behind-the-scenes story of the airplane demonstrates how private enterprise is needed for innovation and economic growth— and that government subsidies usually fail.

Shadow Stats Snapshot


ShadowStats alternate economic indicators are based on the methodology of noted economist John Williams, specialist in government economic reporting.

  • Unemployment:
    BLS: 4.7%
    Shadow Stats: 22.7%
  • Inflation:
    January Year-to-Year: 2.50% (CPI-U*)
    Shadow Stats: 10.3%

*[cpi-u is the Bureau of Labor Statistics inflation rate for all urban consumers]